"Yes: Mexico must be thoroughly chastised! . . . The news of yesterday [at the southern border] has added the last argument wanted to prove the necessity of an immediate Declaration of War by our government toward its southern neighbor.
"We are justified in the face of the world, in having treated Mexico with more forbearance [tolerance] than we have ever yet treated an enemy. . . . We have . . . submitted thus far to a most offensive rejection of an Ambassador personifying the American nation, and waited for years without payment of the claims of our injured merchants. We have sought peace through every avenue, and shut our eyes to many things, which, had they come from England or France, the President would not have dared to pass over without stern and speedy resentment. We have dammed up our memory, of what had passed in the South [Texas] years ago—of devilish massacres of some of our bravest and noblest sons . . . in violation of all the rules of war. . . .
"We think there can be no doubt of the truth of yesterday's news; and we are sure the people here, ten to one, are for prompt and hostilities. . . . Let our arms now be carried with a spirit which shall teach the world that, while we are not forward for a quarrel, America knows how to crush, as well as how to expand!"
Walt Whitman, journalist and poet, editorial in the Brooklyn Eagle, 1846
"President [James K. Polk] in his message, as a pretext for sending our army to invade and conquer the country upon the Rio Grande, says: "Texas by its [legislative] act of December 19, 1836, had declared the [Rio Grande] to be the boundary of that [formerly independent] republic.' . . . The truth is that Texas had agreed upon the Nueces [River] as her boundary. . . .
"If [Mexico] be ours, why does he seek to justify the taking possession of it by references to the fact that Mexico is indebted to some of our people? If it be not ours, and he has taken possession of it in order to compel Mexico to pay those debts, why not say so? The fact that Mexico has not paid the debts due to our citizens can have no legitimate connection with taking possession of [it as] our own soil. But [the president] was obviously conscious that this invasion of the Mexican territory could not be justified. . . .
"When the Executive and Congress openly and avowedly took upon themselves the responsibility of extending and perpetuating slavery by the annexation of Texas, and by the total overthrow and subversion of the Constitution, . . . my confidence in the stability of our institutions was shaken, destroyed. . . . Our Union continues, but our Constitution is gone. . . .
". . . No man regards this war as just. We know, the country knows, and the civilized world are conscious, that it has resulted from a desire to extend and sustain an institution on which the curse of the Almighty most visibly rests."
Joshua Giddings, congressman from Ohio, speech in the United States House of Representatives, 1846
Which of the following comparisons best describes Whitman's and Giddings' arguments about the Mexican-American War?
A
Whitman believed the United States should show patience before war, while Giddings believed the country had tolerated abuses for too long without war.
B
Whitman argued that the war was intended to deter bad behavior, while Giddings argued that the war represented aggression by the United States.
C
Giddings asserted that the nation entered the war as a last resort, while Whitman asserted that the war was unnecessary to achieve the goals of the United States.
D
Giddings claimed that the war had popular support in the United States, while Whitman claimed that most Americans opposed the war.

The comparison that best describes Whitman's and Giddings' arguments about the Mexican-American War is:

C. Giddings asserted that the nation entered the war as a last resort, while Whitman asserted that the war was unnecessary to achieve the goals of the United States.

Whitman's argument, as expressed in the editorial he wrote for the Brooklyn Eagle in 1846, suggests that he believed the United States had already shown considerable forbearance towards Mexico. He emphasized that the United States had sought peace through diplomatic means and had tolerated offensive actions, such as the rejection of an American ambassador and the non-payment of debts owed to American merchants. Whitman argued that the United States should exercise restraint and avoid war, stating that America should not be eager for a quarrel. He believed that the actions of Mexico did not warrant immediate military action and that the United States should focus on diplomatic resolutions instead.

On the other hand, Giddings, a congressman from Ohio, argued in a speech in the United States House of Representatives that the war was not justified and represented aggression by the United States.

He contended that the United States invaded Mexican territory without legitimate justification. Giddings criticized the annexation of Texas and the perceived overthrow of the Constitution as factors that eroded his confidence in the stability of American institutions.

He believed that the war was driven by the desire to extend and perpetuate slavery rather than legitimate reasons. Giddings saw the war as an unnecessary and unjust act on the part of the United States.

Final answer:

In summary, while Whitman argued against immediate military action and emphasized the pursuit of diplomatic solutions, Giddings asserted that the war was an aggressive move by the United States and that it was unnecessary in achieving the goals of the country.

For more questions on Mexican-American War

https://brainly.com/question/5342067

#SPJ8

How did the development of the factory system encourage urbanization?

How can Congress initiate the formal constitutional amendment process?

given the history of rome, the world’s first major republic, what is the consequence of having a "feeble" (or weak) executive?

What connections did the Red Scare have to Truman’s Loyalty Review Program?

Which of the following is not a factor that directly contributes to rainfall in Southeast Asia?
a.sea breezes
b.land
c.reliefs
d.vegetation

2
Type the correct answer in the box.
What weather pattern did Indian farmers depend on the

bring water for their crops?
Indian farmers depended on the
to bring water for their crops.

What effect did the Watergate scandal have on American society?
a.
It affected the economy by causing a decline in manufacturing.
c.
It affected foreign policy in that it persuaded Canada to sign NAFTA.
b.
It affected politics because it made people distrust politicians.
d.
It did not affect American society.


Please select the best answer from the choices provided

A
B
C
D

Write an algebraic expression for the word expression.

the sum of 112 and m

Read the passage.

According to one study, by the year 2025, energy from renewable sources like wind and solar power will be cheaper than energy from coal.

Based on the information provided, what visual information would be most helpful to include with the passage?

a map showing current costs of energy
a chart showing expected world use of coal in 2025
a line graph showing expected changes in energy costs over the next 10 years
a set of photographs showing people using renewable energy in their homes and cars

According to Quincy, what does Mexico call the land between the Nueces River and the Rio Grande?

Which of the following best describes the way public projects are funded? 1. A town government taxes the state and federal governments. 2. A government taxes citizens, in part, to pay for public projects, such as road repair. 3. State governments use their extra money to pay for everyday needs like garbage collection. 4. The federal government taxes local governments so that every person can be taxed several times. ​

Which of the following situations was made possible by the passage of the
Twenty-Sixth Amendment?
A. An 18-year-old veteran votes for an antiwar presidential candidate.
B. An African American farmer receives federal subsidies to improve
his land.
C. An Irish immigrant runs for a seat on his new hometown's city
council.
D. A middle class woman receives the same salary as a man in her
position.

Identify AND describe TWO actions Hitler took to rebuild the strength of Germany between 1933-1939.

Which best describes the inclusion of sitting bull’s encampment in this drawing of the battle of greasy grass?

In the 1850s abolition was not a widely embraced movement in the United States. It was considered radical, extreme, and dangerous. In "What to the Slave Is the Fourth of July?" Frederick Douglass sought not only to convince people of the wrongfulness of slavery but also to make abolition more acceptable to Northern whites.

explain the cartoonist purpose for creating this political cartoon about the great stink?

1. Which of the following does not apply to the early formation of the United Nations?

American involvement in the Western Hemisphere included all of the following except: the defense of the Monroe Doctrine
seizing control over troubled finances
maintaining stable Latin American governments
the Spanish-American War
the Boxer Rebellion

Do you think that demobilization is something that is needed today in a time when American troops are deployed throughout the world in various military efforts to maintain peace and stability in turbulent regions?

The Meiji Restoration in Japan a. concentrated on the reestablishment of feudal principles of decentralized government and native Japanese values. b. forcefully rejected westernization and looked instead to China as its model. c. sent many Japanese abroad to be educated in the ways of the west and adopted many western reforms in political and military organization. d. created a political system rigidly authoritarian in both form and practice. e. successfully accomplished the expulsion of all foreigners from the country.

who did the shoguns serve?
select the best answer from the choices provided a b c d
a. the people
b. regional lords
c. the monarchy
d. the shinto religion please select the best answer from the choices provided a b c d

why did the communist leader, Mao Zedong, enjoy popular support of the people after World War II?

PLEASE HELP ME, I CANT FIND THE ANSWER ANYWHERE??

What are some Short term Causes of the Industrial Revolution!?!?​

1) How did FDR's New Deal change the government for the future? (Include 2 specific
examples of how the government was changed with strong details)
Change 1 (explain in detail) -
Change 2 (explain in detail)

In the 1950s, businesses relocated
to which of the following places?
A. countryside
B. inner cities
C. suburbs

Hey I'm Chloe Can You Help Me I will give brainlest :)
In 1619, Virginia created the first representative government in the colonies. What is a
representative government?
A. a government where everyone gets to vote on what laws are made
B. a government where people vote for the leaders who make the laws
C. a government where one person has all of the power to make the laws

can someone please help me​

What advantage did the floppy disk give computers before the Internet was created? A. It eliminated the need for computers. B. The microchip was eliminated. C. Transfer data from one computer to another.​

World war 2 history question please help me!
which of the following best describes the u,s, governments response to the flood of jewish refugees fleeing nazi persecution and genocide before and during world war ii

which crop did the spanish settlers grew first?