In your response, be sure to address all parts of the question. Use complete sentences; an outline or bulleted list alone is not acceptable.

“The members of the Philadelphia convention which drafted the Constitution were, with a few exceptions, immediately, directly, and personally interested in, and derived economic advantages from, the establishment of the new system. The Constitution was essentially an economic document based upon the concept that the fundamental private rights of property are [superior] to government and morally beyond the reach of popular majorities.”
Charles Beard, historian, An Economic Interpretation of the Constitution of the United States, 1913

“Anxious and uncertain, the convention delegates . . . brought to bear their political experience, their sensitivities to legal loopholes, their commitment to representative government, and they focused their energies and attentions on resolving existing conflicts, correcting existing errors, and protecting . . . against a descent into tyranny. When they were done, they submitted their handiwork to the citizens for ratification rather than attempting to impose it by assassination or military force. In this way, they invited their neighbors to share responsibility for the fate of their experiment in representative government.”
Carol Berkin, historian, A Brilliant Solution: Inventing the American Constitution, 2002

Using the excerpts above, answer (a), (b), and (c).
a. Briefly describe ONE major difference between Beard’s and Berkin’s historical interpretations of the drafting of the United States Constitution.
b. Briefly explain how ONE specific historical event, development, or circumstance in the period 1776–1800 that is not directly mentioned in the excerpts could be used to support Beard’s interpretation.
c. Briefly explain how ONE specific historical event, development, or circumstance in the period 1776–1800 that is not directly mentioned in the excerpts could be used to support Berkin’s interpretation.

Answers

Answer 1

Answer:

a) One major difference between Beard's and Berkin's historical interpretations of the drafting of the United States Constitution is the point of view in which it is written. Charles Beard believes that the Constitution was adopted for economic self-interest while Berkin portrays the conflicts between the delegates during the drafting of the constitution. This was significant because the different interpretations show the development of Unites States government.

Explanation:

hope it helps :)

Answer 2

a) ONE major difference between Charles Beard's and Carol Berkin's interpretations of the drafting of the United States Constitution is that Beard argued that the Constitution was drafted to perpetuate the economic interests of the wealthy.

On the other hand, Berkin's interpretations focus on how the drafting of the Constitution created the national government which allows democratic norms to flourish.

b) ONE specific historical event between the period 1776 - 1800 that supports Beard's economic interpretation of the Constitution is demonstrated by the passage of the Fugitive Slave Act in 1783. The law enshrined slavery into the Constitution, making it possible for slaveholders to recover slaves who had run away.

c) On the other hand, the Shays Rebellion, which forced the drafting of the Constitution and the jettisoning of the Articles of Confederation, showed that the Constitution's drafting resolved past political errors and brought about a representative government.

Thus, Charles Beard's economic interpretations and Carol Berkin's political interpretations enjoy the needed support from historical events, developments, or circumstances.

Learn more: https://brainly.com/question/9215465


Related Questions

Rwanda's government is a parliamentary government. The parliament is made up of two chambers, the Chamber of Deputies and the Senate. Women play a very important role in Rwanda's government. The election of 2003 placed Rwanda at the top of the world ranking with Rwandan women comprising nearly half of the National Assembly.

What is an example of civic participation for many women in Rwanda?
A.
serving on Rwanda's parliament
B.
letting the men run the government
C.
traveling to the United States
D.
helping Rwanda's dictatorship

Answers

1)Although generally perceived to be a genocide by the international community, the 1994 killing of approximately 800,000 Tutsis in Rwanda was seen at the time by Hutus as a response to the assassination of a Hutu president.

Mass killings began after the April 6, 1994, attack on Rwandan President Juvenal Habyarimana and Burundian President Cyprien Ntaryamira, both Hutu, who died after the plane in which they were traveling was shot down.

2) The correct answer is C. The Hutu militia group responsible for carrying out widespread murders in Rwanda in 1994 was the Interahamwe.  

The Interahamwe was a paramilitary group that was formed in Rwanda during its civil war, formed mostly by people of the Hutu ethnic group. These forces, along with elements of the Presidential Guard, were responsible for the deaths of nearly 800,000 people in the Rwandan Genocide in 1994 against the Tutsi ethnic group.

3) The correct answer is B. One significant consequence of the 1994 Rwandan genocide was that over 1 million children were orphaned.

Probably, it will never be known how many deaths caused this genocide. They are calculated between 500,000 and 1,000,000. If they were 800,000 it would be equivalent to 11 percent of the total population and 80% of the Tutsis who lived in the country. In addition, genocide and civil conflict led to the exile of two million Rwandans in then-Zaire, 480,000 in Tanzania, 200,000 in Burundi and 10,000 in Uganda, along with more than a million internally displaced persons.

C hdhsjahdhsjshshshshdhdifidiwhhwgshhdufh

Based on the information in the table , the black death outbreak of the bubonic plague struck Essex County in which of the following periods?

Answers

Answer:

between 1320 and 1350

Explanation:

Based on the information in the table, the black death outbreak of bubonic plague struck the country between 1320 and 1350.

What do you mean by black death?

The black death is the result of the plague due to the infection with the bacteria.

The black death affected the extreme north of England, Scotland, Scandinavia, and other countries. It started between the periods of 1320 and 1350.

Learn more about the black death here:

https://brainly.com/question/12343612

#SPJ2

In 1989, around 100,000 protesters gathered in Tiananmen Square in Beijing, China and demanded
A.
increased wages.
B.
world peace.
C.
democratic reforms.
D.
environmental reforms.

Answers

Answer:

C

Explanation: The Tiananmen Square protests were student-led demonstrations calling for democracy, free speech and a free press in China. There were other protests on Tiananmen square in 1919 and 1976. ... The protests in cities other than Beijing stayed peaceful. On June 4, 1989, the government used force to end the protests.

Which changes were part of the League of Nation’s mandate system? Check all that apply. Turkey was granted independence. Saudi Arabia was put under British control. Iraq was granted independence. Syria was placed under French control. Egypt was placed under Spanish control.

Answers

Answer:

-Turkey was granted independence.

-Syria was placed under French control.

Explanation:

The mandate system was a popular system established in History. The changes were part of the League of Nation’s mandate system are;

Turkey was granted independence.

Syria was placed under French control.

The mandate system was known to be set up by the treaties ending World War I. In this system, the victors of World War I were sent to governing former German and Ottoman territories as mandates from the League.

Mandate as an authorization given by the League of Nations to a member nation to lead a former German or Turkish colony. The territory is known to be mandated territory.

Conclusively, the Mandate System set up different effects that closely looks like colonialism.

Learn more about Mandate System from

https://brainly.com/question/17380247

What did all of the Framers of the Constitution agree to before the convention?

Answers

Answer:

They agreed to work in secret

Explanation:

Hope this helps!

Answer:

They agreed to work in secret

Explanation:

Have a great day!!!! º≈º

Pls pls Pls pls Pls Pls help me pls pls pls pls pls pls ASAP pls pls pls Pls pls Pls pls Pls Pls help me pls pls pls pls pls pls ASAP pls pls pls Pls pls Pls HELPPPP MEEEE I WILL GIVE BRAINLIESTTTTT!!!!!!!!!!!!


How do you think this piece of propaganda helped shape colonial views of what happened the night of the shooting?

Answers

Answer:

I think this piece of propaganda helped shape colonial views of what happened the night of the shooting because in the image it's telling us that the people are marching

Explanation:

Supposing God exists: can God create a stone that God cannot lift?
Why do we wait until night to 'call it a day?'

Answers

Answer:

from my point of view God can create a stone also and can destroy the stone also God can lift the stone also you are thinking that get God creates the stone and doesn't lifted its wrong thinking because god is the creator of the world God create the world beautifully he or she whatever he creates think and create everything and can cause day and night remember one thing that god is the creator of old world god is the creator of me and you also god is creating humans .

I just need the question in red answered

Answers

Answer:

So i'm guessing that the president Reagan had the power to put fairness upon states.

sorry if this didn't help?..

The British constitution_______

What is the answer

Answers

Answer:

it is a unwritten act of parliaments

Explanation:

What do you know about American's Immigrant history? Why were immigrants like Italians not welcome?

Answers

Answer:

Because the immigrants spoke odd, and they didn't have the same color skin as the Americans then.

Explanation:

The answer is above.

Answer:

I thank it is they spoke odd tell me if I am wrong plz and thx

In your own words, explain the historical and cultural significance if Spanish colonization in the Americas. How did it affect the relationship between the Old World and the New World?

Answers

Answer: The Americans followed the Spanish colonization. This affected the relationship between the Old World and the New World because Columbus brought back tons of riches to Spain.

Guys it's my maths exam 9:00 wish me good luck​

Answers

omg good luck!!! you’ll do great :D

Answer:

good luck and shouldn't you be sleeping?

Georgia's unwavering stance on which issue resulted in the state playing an important role at the Constitutional Convention?
A. the institution of slavery
B. the structure of the legislature
C. the process of electing the president D. the use of tariffs by state governments
Help me please!​

Answers

Answer:

I think its the structure of the legislature

Explanation:  hope this helped(:

i just took my test

Georgia's unwavering stance on the issue resulted in the state playing an important role at the Constitutional Convention in the institution of slavery. Thus the correct option is A.

What is Constitution?

A constitution is a fundamental document that defines rules and regulations, laws and legislation as well as the power and authority of the government to conduct the functioning of any country.

The institution of slavery was an issue on which Georgia's uncompromising attitude resulted in the state playing a significant role at the Constitutional Convention.

Georgia banned slavery because it was against its social and economic objectives and comes as the first who made an effort to outlaw black slavery in the country as public policy.

Therefore, option A is appropriate.

Learn more about Constitution, here:

https://brainly.com/question/19411179

#SPJ6

What is the best way to describe the climate of Greece?

A It has long, mild winters and short, cool summers.
B It has short, cold winters and long, humid, wet summers.
C It has short, mild winters and long, hot, dry summers.
D It has long, wet winters and short, mild summers.

Plz hurry I don't have much time left.

Answers

Answer:

C

Explanation:

Greece is in the mediterranean so it has short winters, and also google says that Greece has hot, dry summers.

"The climate of Greece is mediterranean with summers that are usually hot and dry, and the winters that can be quiet cold and wet. ... Summers in Greece are usually very hot, and in July and August temperatures usually reach 30 to 35°C, but sometimes even 40°C and more."

The answer is going to be c

which of the following groups was one part of the new deal coalition?

Answers

Franklin D. Roosevelt forged a coalition that included the Democratic state party organizations, city machines, labor unions, blue collar workers, minorities (including Jews, Southern and Eastern Europeans, and African-Americans), farmers, white Southerners, people on relief, and intellectuals.

why was george washington considered a great military leader for the american war

Answers

Answer:

His leadership managed to fight a far more superior better trained army because of passion and the need for freedom from the crown. Alexander, Caesar, or Napoleon could have beaten him on the battlefield, but Washington was the most principled of all of them.

Explanation:

What was the relationship between the Shona people and the groups along the Swahili Coast?

Answers

Answer: They traded with each other. language group. How are modern-day Shona similar to their ancestors?

Explanation:What was the relationship between the Shona people and the groups along the Swahili Coast?

Answer:

they used those people to sell off as slaves

Explanation:

What did the state of obligation provide to

Answers

No because it is impossible to hit a home run while strangled

What did John White find when he returned to Roanoke after several years in England?

Answers

Answer:

The settlement was deserted and the only clue left behind was the word "croatoan" etched onto a tree.

Explanation:

^

can someone help me with 2 questions please? i’m in 6th grade

Answers

Answer:

I can give it a try but the questions aren't on here

what do you call a member of congress who intrduces a bill

Answers

Answer:

The bill sponsor

Explanation:

After the idea for a bill is developed and the text of the bill is written, a Member of Congress must officially introduce the bill in Congress by becoming the bill's sponsor. Representatives usually sponsor bills that are important to them and their constituents.

Mark brainlist pls

Which was a reason people moved west?
A.People were trying to escape repression
B.People had been displaced by war
C.People couldn't afford the expensive land in the east
D.All of the above

Answers

Answer:

Explanation:

All of the above i believe. Sorry if I'm wrong

Which factor was a motivation of the nativists in the United States during the nineteenth century? *

A(the desire for land
B(prejudice against immigrants
C(loyalty to the Pope
D(opposition to slavery

Answers

Answer:

Prejudice against immigrants

Explanation:

The French and Indian war was a battle over control of the Ohio Valley.


Please select the best answer from the choices provided

T
F

Answers

Answer:

I'm pretty sure it's True

Explanation:

France wanted to expand their colony to the Ohio River Valley, but the British wouldn't let them because they were using it for their colonies. France's move repeatedly brought conflict to the British colonies, and a series of battles led to the official declaration of war by the British in 1756. But because of the finance of the future Prime Minister, the British won.

Answer:

t

Explanation:

i got it right

Identify three events that eventually led to the decline of feudalism. Briefly explain how each weakened the feudal system.
Text to speech

Answers

I think feudalism because of the crusades war, the bubonic plague and the Magna carta

The three events that eventually led to the decline of feudalism was the Hundred Years War, the bubonic plague and the Magna carta.

How did plague led to the decline of feudalism?

There was a significant population decline and a need for workers due to plague. Many peasants fled the feudal manors in search of better opportunities in cities. This weakened the feudal manor system and deprived the lords of power.

As, monarchs did not rely on lords to supply knights to fight during the war, power shifted from lords to monarchs and common people. Knights and castles were no longer useful in the war due to technological advances. Commoners fought in the war in order to gain more influence and power afterward.

The Magna Carta weakened the monarchs' power by establishing the concept of rights and liberties that even monarchs could not violate. It also stated that the monarch should rule in accordance with the advice of those who govern. The model parliament gave commoners and nobles a voice in government, shifting power to the people and weakening feudalism.

To learn more about the decline of feudalism, click here:

https://brainly.com/question/10985048

#SPJ2

What was the importance of interchangeable parts during the Industrial Revolution of the early 19th century?

a. They allowed for the mass production and reduced price of producing American goods


b. They brought fame to the international inventor Eli Whitney


c. They were first used in production of the cotton gin


d, They revolutionized the cotton gin

Answers

Answer:

a) They allowed for the mass production and reduced price of producing American goods

Answer:

a. They allowed for the mass production and reduced price of producing American goods

Brainliest to first answer!!!!!
Create a contextualizing statement for the claim below.
Consecrated in the thirteenth century and located in Jenne, Mali, the Great Mosque is one of the finest examples of West African Islamic architecture.

Answers

Answer:02.07 Social Problems and Solutions Chart

I believed that the Problem was successfully addressed because of the fact that people up to this date have abided by it

The Fair labor Standards act was passed which basically outlawed all of child labor

No it is not an issue today because it is against the law for certain aged children to be working

For the most part yes it has been, this is because more buildings were build to ensure that more people could live in them

More Tenements were built because of the Tenement Building owners realizing they could make more money if they had more Tenement housing buildings

Yes and No because there are still people that are homeless but there are enough buildings for them to live in

Child Labor

Tenement

Housing

Lack of

Protection

It was never really addressed because of the living arrangements in cities such as the building being made of wood and candles being the only source of light and burning down building forcing people out onto the street which made thieves and pickpockets thrive

Yes it has been addressed successfully because more safety precautions have been taken when making buildings

Yes, for the most part because there are security cameras and protection everywhere such as police officers and fire fighters

Explanation: put them in a chart

what was a main cause of the iraqi civil war

Answers

Answer:

I believe the answer is C i'm 85% sure

Explanation:

Answer:

c

Explanation

What is the definition of terrorism?

Answers

Answer:the unlawful use of violence and intimidation, especially against civilians, in the pursuit of political aims.

Explanation:

Answer:

Terrorism is defined in the Code of Federal Regulations as “the unlawful use of force and violence against persons or property to intimidate or coerce a government, the civilian population, or any segment thereof, in furtherance of political or social objectives”

Explanation:

Why did Lincoln’s election trigger the secession of the Southern states?

PLEASE HELP!!!

Answers

Answer:

The Southern states were already pretty angry, but when Lincon got elected, they exploded. Southerners were feeling the threat of Lincoln and believed that he would put an end on slavery and its expansion. The North was gaining more power, and the slave states had deteriorated in their influence and presence in the House of Representatives. The South Feared that the North had more power over them and that the North would be able to essentially boss them around. Lincon's Election only made this paranoia worse.

Explanation:

Answer:because Lincoln wanted to stop slavery and the south wanted it to be a thing still

Explanation:

Other Questions
which of the following rivers is the longest in the north america how do simplify -15.6/-4 0.5 mi = 2, 640 ftO TrueFalse What is history of A Country's Sphere of Influence 1) which sentence is punctuated correctly?a) In the first place modern communicators, have made it possible forb) In the first place modern communicators have made it possible for nc) In the first place, modern communicators have made it possible ford) In the first place modern communicators have made it possible, for2) I _ a good student.a) wereb) beenc) amd) woree) is3) good friends.a) They'reb) They arec) Their Look at the PDFs and then answer the question -3-I"M GIVING BRANINLLEST TO THE BEST ANSWER UwU Completa. Complete the sentences with definite or indefinite articles.1. Mi apartamento est en (1) edificio. El edificio es muy alto.2. Tenemos (2) bao pequeo, pero tiene (3) ventana.3. No tenemos (4) sala separada. La sala es parte del comedor.4. La casa tiene (5) ventanas grandes, pero las ventanas de los baos son pequeas.,5. En (6) dormitorio de mis padres los techos son altos. what is the price of 29.99 after a 33 1/3 markdown? ScenarioHemoglobin is a protein that helps transport oxygen in specialized red blood cells. Oxygen is a required component for cellular metabolism (energy production), which powers important cellular processes. A person with sickle cell anemia does not produce normal hemoglobin, as seen below.PromptHow is DNA responsible for sickle cell anemia?Claim: (1-2 sentences)Evidence: (4 pieces of evidence are needed to get full credit.)Reasoning: ( A minimum of 3 sentences using vocabulary terms are needed to get full credit.) About 80% of beef supply is controlled by 4 companies. Name them. In one to two sentences, describe contributions made by immigrants in America I just need the question in red answered The student toses a ball into the air and then watches the ball fall back down to earth. When does the ball have the most potential energy Graph y=3/4+4 Please! I need help! For babysitting, Zou Jing charges a flat fee of $10, plus $15 per hour. Write an equation for the cost, C, after h hours of babysitting. How much money will she make if she baby-sits 5 hours? How many hours does Zou Jing need to babysit to afford a PS5 ($500)? When Did you heard about coronavirus ? The use of headings separates the parts of a how-to manual in the Interest of achleving which purpose? A. making the text more visually appealing B. allowing the reader to quickly scan the text C. keeping the reader engaged in the text Find the unknown value in the proportion.4/7=?/14. please help Triangle ABC is located in the third quadrant of a coordinate plane. If triangle ABC is reflected across the axis to obtain triangle, ABC, which statement is true? A. Triangle ABC lies in quadrant II and is congruent to Triangle ABC B. Triangle ABC lies in quadrant IV and is congruent to Triangle ABC C. Triangle ABC lies in quadrant II and is not congruent to Triangle ABC D. Triangle ABC lies in quadrant IV and is not congruent to Triangle ABC MATH QUESTION PLS HELP!