In Bartleby, the Scrivener by Herman Melville the employer went to great lengths to keep the employee and employer relationship within reasonable limits. However, this was impossible as the reader would later realize that Bartleby was mentally unwell.
The suggested theme here is that obligations are essential but must be kept within socially reasonable limits if the legal duties of both parties have been fully satisfied.
How would one summarize Bartleby, the Scrivener by Herman Melville?The novel's setting, for example, is not clinical; the main exchanges take place between the CEO of a law business and an employee who politely but forcefully refuses to carry out his clearly outlined obligations. The stakes of each needed task are not as obvious and severe as in medicine.
But the narrator, Melville, was writing symbolically here, at a period in his own career when he chose not to write the sort of fiction that was expected of him, as well as not to fulfill the presumed requirements of his profession.
Learn more about Bartleby:
https://brainly.com/question/28053551
#SPJ1
Which question would most likely be answered by reading the exposition of a
story?
Answer: B . What kind of story is this ?
Explanation:
100 POINTS ANF BRAINLIEST!
04.02 Another View
Directions: Save this worksheet. Read both articles and complete both parts.
Part One: Fill out the Compare and Contrast Chart.
Part Two: Write a paragraph how these articles compare and contrast using details from your chart.
Article 1
The Case for Mars
By Alexander Fisher
A mission to Mars should be the next step for NASA. There are many reasons why going to Mars is important. First, Mars is the most likely planet for us to colonize. No matter how expensive, we need to work on getting there as soon as possible. Furthermore, the technology that we would need to develop to send humans to Mars would directly benefit our economy here on Earth. Just look at the money-making products that have already resulted from NASA’s space efforts: invisible braces, water filters, cordless vacuums, to name just a few.
Although we have already sent robots to Mars, robots can’t take the place of humans when it comes to studying the planet. A robot may break down. Also, it takes robots much longer to cover the same amount of ground than it would a human. Think how much faster we could learn about the planet if we sent humans to work alongside the robots!
Finally, claims that there will be significant health problems for people who travel to Mars are wrong. Studies have shown that radiation levels on Mars are not lethal to humans. Sure, we would have to live in a dome at first, but over time, we could use science to change the atmosphere and make it possible to go outside, just like on Earth! The choice is clear. We need to go to Mars now!
Article 2
Mars—A Waste of Time and Money
By Juniper Springs
While it might be fun to imagine traveling to Mars one day, now is not the time to go. For one thing, it is too dangerous. The atmosphere of the planet is more carbon dioxide than oxygen, and it’s very cold. While there are claims that the radiation levels on the planet are not lethal to humans, that does not mean they aren’t dangerous. We don’t yet know what the long-term health effects will be. As of now, we do not have a solution for this problem. It is foolish to think a dome would be able to protect us from all of the radiation.
It would also be impossible to build one large enough to house as many people as would want to go. Also, going to Mars will be expensive. Why spend money traveling to a planet that is so dangerous and far away? That money could be better spent addressing problems here on Earth.
Furthermore, it is unwise to think any inventions that come about as a result of our race to Mars would make up for the cost of getting there. We are already able to send robots to Mars. It won’t be long until our technology is so advanced that a robot will be able to do the same tasks as a human. It is not necessary to go to Mars right now.
Part 1 Graphic Organizer
Fill out the Compare and Contrast Chart based on the two articles in this worksheet.
Part 2 Reflection
Write a paragraph that answers the following questions. Be sure to use complete sentences.
1. Did the authors have similar or opposing views?
2. Did the authors use the same points of comparison? Explain with examples.
3. Did the authors support their views in the same or different ways?
4. Did both focus most on appeals to logic or to emotion?
1. The authors had opposing views.
2. No, they didn't because of the difference of views, their comparison couldn't have had the same points.
3. They supported their ideas but in different ways.
4. They used both logic and emotion, using the advantage of adventure and a new planet to discover to allow us all live somewhere new.
What figurative language is I was a human punching bag?
Answer:
I was a punching bag is a metaphor because it isn’t comparing two things using like or as. Instead, it is comparing two things directly.
Explanation:
hope this helped!
Which technique is used to check the meaning of certain nonverbal behaviors of the speaker?.
The technique that is used to check the meaning of certain nonverbal behaviors of the speaker is looking away.
Nonverbal behaviors refer to the transmission of messages or signals by way of nonverbal policies to a degree of eye contact, first expressions, gestures, posture, and nonverbal communication. It requires utilizing friendly cues, gestures, distance and tangible surroundings/image, voice, and touch.
Nonverbal behavior procedures involve your posture, first expressions, and eye contact. We all use these suggestions in common discourse, even though unconsciously. When the public is thinking, doubtful, or talking in a non-articulate manner, they are likely to avoid it by turning away. Therefore, The technique that is used to check the meaning of certain nonverbal behaviors of the speaker is looking away.
To know more about Nonverbal behavior refer to: https://brainly.com/question/28205531
#SPJ4
Explain how the author uses the other raft of refugees to impact the situation on Isabel's boat
in refugee chapter 44
Answer:
Instead of capturing her boat, the Coast Guard goes after a raft carrying other refugees, while Isabel and her companions paddle for shore as fast as they can.
Explanation:
I think
Answer: I love this book
Explanation:
What are the main reasons parents do not stay on good terms with their adolescent children? Give at least two arguments to support your opinion. Can you give a few pieces of advice how relationship between parents and their adolescent children could be improved? Give at least 3 pieces of advice.
Conflict between parents and adolescents can result from many of the changes that characterise adolescence.
Adolescents develop a stronger aptitude for logical reasoning, which prompts them to demand explanations for things they previously took for granted and the opportunity to present the opposing viewpoint (Maccoby, 1984).
Particularly throughout adolescence, when it's common for teenagers to seek independence and a break from their parents, this can get worse. Other reasons why families argue include disagreements over ideas, a lack of communication, changes in the family (like a new baby or divorce), sibling rivalry, or problems with discipline.
What are the primary issues affecting parent-child relationships?
Lack of boundaries, rejection, restriction, and overprotection, as well as overindulgence, substance misuse, and excessive expectations from children, are some of these issues. Parent-child interaction
Learn more about Adolescents https://brainly.com/question/9506316
#SPJ9
In paragraph 12, what does the
description of the father's reaction
emphasize?
A. his frustration that his son is
upset again
B. his realization that it is a serious
situation
C. his anger that the deliveries will
be affected
D. his impatience at the irresponsibility
of the boys
Answer:
B. his realization that it is a serioussituation
PLEASE GIVE BRAINLIEST THANK YOU!!!
Read the excerpt from "Ain’t I a Woman?” by Sojourner Truth.
I could work as much and eat as much as a man—when I could get it—and bear the lash as well! And ain’t I a woman? I have borne thirteen children, and seen most all sold off to slavery, and when I cried out with my mother’s grief, none but Jesus heard me! And ain’t I a woman?
What evidence does the speaker use to support her claim in this excerpt?
her disagreements with men
her experiences from her life
her relationship with religion
her conversations with others
HELP HELPPPPP please
The evidence that the speaker uses to support her claim in this excerpt is this: her experiences from her life.
What evidence does the speaker use to support her claim?From the words in the text, we can see that the speaker used experiences from her life to support what she was saying. In this excerpt, we can see that Truth mentioned the fact that she had suffered a lot in life and had borne problems that many would have said were meant for women. She was trying to say that there was no significant reason why a woman should be denied the privileges that men enjoyed.
The personal experiences from her life that she used to back up her points were the fact that she had borne 13 children and that she had watched these children as they were sent into slavery. She had suffered all these things despite being a woman.
Learn more about Sojourner Truth here:
https://brainly.com/question/963143
#SPJ1
What is the central idea in the first paragraph of Roosevelt’s speech?
Answer: In the first paragraph of his speech, Roosevelt tried to describe how the United States was being an innocent victim of unprovoked Japanese aggression.
Explanation:
Why have claudius and gertrude invited rosencrantz and guildenstern to elsinore?.
The main reason why Claudius and Gertrude invited Rosencrantz and Guildenstern to Elsinore is to help figure out what is bothering Hamlet as he has been acting very strangely indeed.
What is a Narration?This refers to the telling of a story that is used in order to show the series of actions that occurs so that a reader or audience would be able to understand the scenes and story.
Hence, it can be seen that based on the complete text about Hamlet, he has been acting crazy in court, and his friends Claudius and Gertrude are worried so they invite Rosencrantz and Guildenstern to Elsinore to help find out.
Read more about Hamlet here:
https://brainly.com/question/8182660
#SPJ1
which of the following statements is true about nonverbal communication?
a. Nonverbal communication has a minimal influence on the total emotional impact of a message.
b. Verbal communication and nonverbal communication comprise distinct spheres of interaction and rarely interconnect.
c. Most nonverbal messages convey information in lieu of verbal communication.
d. Being skilled at nonverbal communication is linked to popularity, attractiveness, and socioemotional well-being.
Because it facilitates or enhances verbal communication, nonverbal communication is crucial. When verbal and nonverbal cues are consistent, trust is increased.The answer is Verbal communication and nonverbal communication comprise distinct spheres of interaction and rarely interconnect.
Speaking loudly and clearly, as well as using nonverbal cues, are all essential components of effective communication.One way of transmitting information from one form or person to another is through communication.The act of communicating entails utilising words or signs that another person can understand. Both verbal and nonverbal means of communication, such as employing signs, may be used.People converse with one another and exchange information verbally or nonverbally to express their feelings, thoughts, expressions, likes, dislikes, opinions, and anything else.Verbal communication is the process by which people convey information by speaking it aloud.
To know more about Communication visit:
https://brainly.com/question/14279869
#SPJ4
The story of “The Cask of Amontillado” is told from the first person perspective. How reliable/ unreliable do you believe the narrator is? Are there any ways that the narrator might be manipulating the truth? Use examples from the text to support your choice.
The Central Narrator Or evil narrator is Montresor. He is committed to advancing his own, cold, ruth-less, vio-lent, cun-ning, and vin-dictive point of view. He doesn't mind informing us about tor-turing and ki=lling Fortunato since, in his opinion, it was the just and moral thing to do.
Edgar Allan Poe's short story "The Cask of Amontillado" (often spelled "The Casque of Amontillado" was first printed in the November 1846 edition of Godey's Lady's Book. The plot is a guy exacting terrible retribution on a buddy who, in his opinion, has humiliated him. The play is set around carnival in an unknown Italian city in an unspecified year. The plot centres around a person being buried alive—in this case, by immurement—as in many of Poe's writings and in accordance with the 19th-century obsession with the issue. Like in "The Black Cat" and "The Tell-Tale Heart," Poe tells the tale from the perspective of the murderer.
To know more about the Cask of Amontillado:
brainly.com/question/14123711
#SPJ1
What is the purpose of "enormous amounts of food" in the following sentence:
→ During the summer bears eat enormous amounts of food in preparation for their winter hibernation.
- It is an adverbial clause that explains how bears eat.
- It is a noun phrase that acts as the object of the verb eat.
- It is a prepositional phrase that provides more information about bears.
- It is an independent clause that provides more information about hibernation.
The purpose of "enormous amounts of food" in the following sentence:
→ During the summer bears eat enormous amounts of food in preparation for their winter hibernation" is that B. It is a noun phrase that acts as the object of the verb eat.
What is a Sentence?This refers to the use of words that are used to communicate between and among different people that makes complete sense and contains a subject and predicate.
Hence, it can be seen that based on the given sentence that talks about the huge amount of food eaten by bears, this is a noun phrase that acts as the object of the verb eat.
Read more about sentences here:
https://brainly.com/question/552895
#SPJ1
Coming in January is the annual summer carnival and here is why you should attend. First, there are activities for all ages. This year, the activities including a fishpond game for younger children, beanbag toss for older children, and relay races for children and adults alike. Secondly, each activity provides prizes such as yo-yos, bug-eyed glasses, and light-up gifts. Winning a prize always adds excitement to any activity. The best part is the costume contest. It is funny to see how children can be creative through face painting, wigs, and costumes. Adults and children can laugh and have fun at the annual summer carnival. If you are looking for a lot of fun this weekend, attending this event is worth it.
The writing style of the above passage is; Persuasive.
What is the writing style of the passage?
The writing style of the passage above is persuasive. A persuasive writing style is one that is aimed at convincing a reader to take action in the line being promoted by the writer.
In the concluding portion of this text, we can see encouragement for all who are looking to have a lot of fun this weekend to attend the event being touted. The aim of the positive descriptions given about this annual summer carnival is to motivate the reader to attend it. Thus, the passage has a persuasive writing style.
Learn more about the persuasive writing style here:
https://brainly.com/question/25867313
#SPJ1
The text repeats the word deport and related words, such as deportation. How does this repetition serve the author’s purpose?.
The text re-peats the word deport and rel-ated words, such as deportation. This repetition ser-ves the author's pur-pose by - It empha-sizes the pote-ntial risks many immigrants face.
What is the purpose of deportation?Some of the most com-mon reasons for deportation are : An indi-vidual violates the terms of their immi-gration status (green card, non immi-grant visa, etc.) An indivi-dual was inadmissible at the ti-me where they enter-ed the country or adjust-ed their status.
What is the main purpose of immigration?Immigration is the pro-cess of mov-ing to a new cou-ntry or region with the inten-tion of stay-ing and living there.
To know more about deportation click below:
brainly.com/question/13543610
#SPJ4
Select the correct answer.
Keisha needs to organize the main concepts in her research paper. She wants to cover three central ideas—how DDT affects humans, how DDT affects animals, and how DDT affects plants. Which would be the best way for Keisha to format her paper?
A.
by increasing the font size
B.
by underlining keywords
C.
by using section headings
D.
by listing bullet points
Answer:
b
Explanation:
By underlining keywords would be the best way for Keisha to format her paper. Hence, option B is correct.
What are the effects of DDT to humans?DDT exposure at low ambient concentrations may have unclear consequences on human health. Human symptoms after exposure to large levels may include nausea, tremors or shakiness, and seizures. The liver and reproductive were affected, according to laboratory animal research. DDT is thought to be a potential human carcinogen.
When consumed, DDT is mildly to moderately acutely hazardous to mammals, including people. view the laboratory testing box. 113 to 800 milligrams per kilogram of body weight, or mg/kg, is the acute oral LD50.
DDT usage was outlawed in the US in 1972. DDT is still used in several non-American nations to keep mosquitoes that cause malaria at bay. DDT and its associated compounds linger in the environment and in the tissues of animals for a very long time.
Thus, option B is correct.
For more information about effects of DDT to humans, click here:
https://brainly.com/question/1657474
#SPJ2
Why does Toby sit on Parker during a seizure?
Question 5 options:
Parker does not want Toby to bark or nip at his mother.
Parker can hug Toby during a seizure so he can calm down.
Toby wants to make sure Parker does not hurt himself.
The dog trainer told Mandy to have Toby sit on Parker.
Answer:
C
Explanation:
3. What details does Gary Paulsen use to describe
the appearance and expression of the wife of
the heart attack victim? Why might Paulsen
include these details? Cite evidence from the
text to support your answer. PLEASE HELLPP
Answer: The expressions of the wife and the victim was that the victim’s face was gray and that he was holding his left shoulder he also smiled sheepishly at Gary.
Explanation: I know this because the text states that,” His face was gray and he was holding his left shoulder with his right hand. He looked at me and smiled sheepishly, as if to apologize for the inconvenience, and started to say something but then stopped and looked again at the floor in what soldiers call the thousand-yard stare.”
what is the philosophical issue presented in plato's euthyphro? discuss the argument from atheism that shafer-landau discusses and why he believes it's unsound. how is this argument related to plato's euthyphro? discuss all of the backstory and conversation between socrates and euthyphro leading up to the dilemma. discuss both versions of the dilemma, the implications of each side, and objections to divine command theory. next discuss the distinctions between universality, absolutism, and objectivity as well as shafer-landau's discussion of moral principles and moral facts, and how this speaks to his case for ethical objectivism.
The philoso-phical issue prese-nted in Plato's Euthyphro is - Plato's dia-log called Euthy-phro relates a discuss-ion that took place bet-ween Socrates and Euthyphro concern-ing the mean-ing of piety, or that virtue usu-ally regard-ed as a man-ner of living that ful-fills one's duty both to gods and to human-ity.
The quest-ion, "Do the gods love piety becau-se it is pious, or is it pious bec-ause the gods love it?" is one of the gre-at quest-ions posed in the history of philo-sophy. It sug-gests a distinction bet-ween an essen-tialist pers-pective and a convention-alist perspective.
The Euthyphro Prob-lem. an act is moral-ly per-missible if and only God does not for-bid it. The Euthyphro Quest-ion: “Is an action wrong beca-use God forbids it or does God for-bid it because it is wro-ng?”
To know more about Plato's Euthyphro click below:
brainly.com/question/17740077
#SPJ4
juan is finishing writing his specific purpose. he brainstorms about his specific purpose and finally settles on three topics he plans on talking about during his speech. what are these three topics called? group of answer choices generalized topics main topics main points
The three topics that Juan sets out to talk about during his speech are called main points.
What is the main point?
The definition from the main point of any speech is the key information or argument contained in the speech. In other words, the main point is what the audience should remember. The main point become the most important part to be presented so that your speech achieves its specific goals and it is useful to help build the speech.
Each main point offers one concept or makes one assertion that advances the presentation's primary idea. Once you have identified your specific objective, you can now consider how to best convert that specific purpose into a series of main points.
Learn more about main point here: brainly.com/question/14843157
#SPJ4
the italian language varies significantly between milan, rome, naples, and palermo. these varieties are an example of * 1 point pidgins. dialects. lingua franca. language groups. idioms.
Option A: These variants serve as an illustration of a dialect.
A dialect is a subgroup's version of the language. A person's dialect is reflected in their accent. In this way, a person's accent might occasionally reveal their place of origin. Standard accent, southern American language variety, African American conversational English, and Appalachia dialect are a few examples of dialects.
For many areas of France, there are up to 28 distinct accents or dialects. Included among them are the dialects of Alsace, Lorraine, Champenois, Picard, Normandy, Breton, Tourangeau, Orléanais, Berrichon, Parisian, Burgundy, Marseille, Corsica, Lyon, Gascony, and Languedoc.
Learn more about dialects at
https://brainly.com/question/28847177?referrer=searchResults
#SPJ4
children of authoritarian parents tend to be ____ ,overly shy, and lack self- esteem
Answer:
Diffident
Explanation:
Diffident means modest or shy because of a lack of self-esteem. So I think that's the answer.
Answer:
smarter
Explanation:
a chinese and a dutch speaker will experience similar challenges when trying to learn english as a second language.
a chinese and a dutch speaker will not experience similar challenges when trying to learn english as a second language.
One of the most difficult tasks a brain can perform is learning a foreign language. The effort required to switch between linguistically complicated structures is what makes learning a foreign language so challenging. Learning to think in another language is likewise difficult.
It requires patience, effort, and devotion. Some of us find it quite difficult to start learning a new language. The alphabet is almost always the first step in learning a language, which might be challenging for some people and each language speaks for itself.
To know more about second language here
https://brainly.com/question/14376760
#SPJ4
Ramayana is an ancient Hindu epic that explores the life of Rama or Ramachandra, a principal deity of Hindu worship. In some traditions, he is
even considered the Supreme Being. Based on what you have learned thus far, would this excerpt of Ramayana be considered a Personal
Legend? Why or why not? In a 5-paragraph essay, support your claim with specific evidence from both texts.
The passage to which the question refers will be considered a Personal Legend if it presents the concept of a life's purpose or a spiritual calling that the individual cannot refuse.
Stories that present the concept of Personal Legend"The Alchemist" by Paulo Coelho."Budah" by Osamo Tesuka."Call of the Wild" by Jack London.Personal Legend is a term that refers to an extremely deep desire, even being described as a desire of the soul, a purpose that must be fulfilled so that the individual feels happy and at peace.
This term is also associated with a spiritual call that makes the individual has a very strong goal, which makes him enter into a great adventure to conquer it.
In this case, the excerpt from "Ramayana" presents the Personal Legend, if it shows an uncontrollable desire or a great calling.
Unfortunately, you didn't show that excerpt. This prevents me from being able to give you an exact answer, but I hope I helped you find the answer you need.
Learn more about "Ramayana:"
https://brainly.com/question/9172051
#SPJ1
______ are created when a financial institution takes a group of loans, bundles them together, securitizes these loans as bonds, and sells these bonds to the investors.
Answer: Securitization
Explanation:
Read the excerpt from "What Does American Democracy Mean to Me?” by Mary McLeod Bethune.
We are rising out of the darkness of slavery into the light of freedom. Here my race has been afforded [the] opportunity to advance from a people 80 percent illiterate to a people 80 percent literate; . . . from total disfranchisement to participation in government; from the status of chattels to recognized contributors to the American culture.
Which statement best evaluates the effectiveness of the speaker’s argument?
It is effective because it mentions specific ways the lives of African Americans have improved.
It is not effective because it focuses on efforts to help African Americans learn to read.
It is not effective because it fails to highlight important achievements of African Americans.
It is effective because it explains how many African Americans are in government.
HELP HELP HELP PLEASE HELP
The statement that best evaluates the effectiveness of the speaker’s argument is this: It is effective because it mentions specific ways the lives of African Americans have improved.
Which statement explains the effectiveness of the speaker's words?The statement that explains the effectiveness of the speaker's words is the first statement that points out the fact that the speaker mentioned specific ways in which the lives of African Americans have improved. The speaker mentioned specific figures that highlighted the increase in the betterment of the intellect of African Americans.
He specifically mentioned that 80% of the people had now advanced from being illiterate to becoming literate. He also said that his people had advanced from being totally disenfranchised to becoming participants in government. So, the speaker's words were important because they mentioned specific ways in which people's lives have improved. This would make the readers grab the point and not miss out on it.
Learn more about American Democracy here:
https://brainly.com/question/1222510
#SPJ1
When the piano that Rose Mary wanted ends up in the backyard, Rose Mary says, “Most pianists never get the chance to play in the great out-of-doors, and now the whole neighborhood can enjoy the music too” (53). What does this tell us about Rose Mary’s character? From the glass castle
What the above statement tells us about Rose Mary is that she sees the positive sides of things. Unlike others who tend to see the negative sides of matters, Rose Mary portrayed the positive things.
What describes the personality of Rose Mary?From her statement above, Roe Mary can be aptly described as an optimistic individual who sought the bright sides of things.
Instead of becoming sad at the fact that the piano she wanted ended up in the backyard, she was able to acknowledge that most pianists do not ever get the chance to play in the great out-doors and now the entire neighborhood can also enjoy the music. So, Rose Mary was positive.
Learn more about the glass castle here:
https://brainly.com/question/7575146
#SPJ1
How does Krulwich convey his purpose in the essay? Cite evidence from the text in
your response.
Krulwich convey his purpose through syntax, language, concepts etc.
What are the components by which purpose is conveyed ?The way a sentence is put together helps the author convey tone, intent, or effect. Details chosen include facts, conditions, traits, methods, etc. Any organizational tool is a form of rhetorical structure. Utilizing a timeline of events, plot, conflict, characterisation, setting, and other storytelling components‐
Language Manipulation: The author used diction and syntax with skill.Putting two concepts side by side is known as juxtaposing them (showing a before and after effect, for instance).Figures of Speech: Ingenious contrasts (similes, metaphors, personification, etc.)In mature writing, mature diction, diversified syntax, and good paragraph arrangement work together to convey a precise and insightful evaluation, analysis, impression, or declaration.Allusion: References to figures from literature, the arts, science, or history.To know more about Syntax click :
https://brainly.com/question/18362095
#SPJ1
Ms. Michaels surveyed her class on whether they preferred free time at the beginning of class or at the end of class. If the ratio of students who prefer free time at the beginning of class to students who prefer free time at the end of class is 12 over 19, what does the ratio 12 over 19 represent?
A 19 students prefer free time at the beginning of class, and 12 students prefer free time at the end of class.
B 19 students prefer free time at the beginning of class, and 31 students prefer free time at the end of class.
C12 students prefer free time at the beginning of class, and 19 students prefer free time at the end of class.
D 31 students prefer free time at the beginning of class, and 12 students prefer free time at the end of class.
Based on the fact that Ms. Michaels surveyed her class on whether they preferred free time at the beginning of class or at the end of class and found that students who prefer free time at the end of class are 12 over 19, the thing which the ratio 12 over 19 represents is C. 12 students prefer free time at the beginning of class, and 19 students prefer free time at the end of class.
What is a Ratio?This refers to the quantitative relation that is used to show the relation between two variables, which shows the number of times one is contained in the other.
Hence, it can be seen that based on the result of the survey by Ms. Michaels about the preference of the students about free time at the beginning of class or at the end of class, the meaning of the ratio is that 12 students prefer free time at the beginning of class, and 19 students prefer free time at the end of class.
Read more about ratios here:
https://brainly.com/question/13513438
#SPJ1
helppp plsssss
can you please help me with this?